Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) took legal action against Stoner Cats, a project that created and sold non-fungible tokens (NFTs) to the public. The NFTs, which were unique and comparable to numbered physical prints, were sold for over $8 million. However, the SEC determined that this constituted an unregistered sale of securities. As a result, Stoner Cats settled the charges by paying a penalty, while neither admitting nor denying guilt.
SEC Commissioners Hester Peirce and Mark Uyeda issued a statement in response to the SEC’s enforcement action against Stoner Cats. They criticized the decision, referring to the NFT sale as “fan crowdfunding” and highlighting its common practice in the world of art. The Commissioners drew parallels between NFTs and collectibles like “Star Wars collectibles sold in the 1970s” and argued that applying securities laws in the same way to both physical collectibles and NFTs would stifle artists’ creativity due to legal ambiguities. They suggested that instead of arbitrary enforcement actions, clear guidelines should be established for artists and creators using NFTs to support their creative endeavors and build fan communities.
Chair Gary Gensler’s SEC has refrained from offering clear guidance on digital assets, asserting that they are all securities except for Bitcoin. However, Congress has been slow to enact legislation that provides a better definition of when a digital asset should be classified as a security or something else. This lack of clarity has caused confusion within the digital asset sector and impeded innovation.
Commissioners Peirce and Uyeda believe that applying securities laws to Stoner Cats’ case is illogical. However, they can do little besides dissenting until there is a change in the SEC’s leadership or Congress approves legislation that addresses the current opaque regulatory environment. The likelihood of such changes is low unless there is a shift in the political landscape during the 2024 elections.
Follow crowdfundingmagazine on Instagram: @crowdfundingmagazine_it